Mystery and pop culture aficionados may have heard the term “Mandela Effect,” a slightly disturbing phenomenon in which a large group of people misremembering something collectively. That may sound like a strange thing to name, but that’s because it happens often enough. Don’t believe us? What was the name of the beloved Bear family in the books? Many would say they’re the “Berenstein Bears,” when they’re actually the Berenstain Bears. There are many surprising examples of this throughout pop culture, including in some of the best-known movies of our time. That may be hard to believe, so we’re going to dig through some of our favorite examples.
Videos by ComicBook.com
For those curious, the term Mandela Effect was coined by Fiona Broome. It’s inspired by a popular historical misconception, in which a shocking number of people believe that Nelson Mandela died while in prison during the 1980s (when, in reality, Nelson Mandela lived until 2013). While there are still many theories to explain the how and why of it all, it’s still fascinating to look at real-life examples of things society has collectively misremembered or mistaken, especially in beloved movies.
1) Star Wars Misquote
Let’s start off with an obvious example of the Mandela Effect: a misquote from Star Wars: The Empire Strikes Back. Most fans (and plenty of non-fans) remember the iconic moment in which Darth Vader reveals that he is Luke Skywalker’s father. It blew our minds and changed the name of the game. So, one might think that we’d all remember the exact quote with precision, right?
Interestingly, a large subset of people truly believe the quote in question is “Luke, I am your father.” While that makes for a dramatic one-off line, that isn’t how it went in the moment. What Vader actually says is, “No, I am your father.” In the context of the scene, this specific quote makes a lot more sense, but even we have to admit it doesn’t sound quite as good as the more quoted version.
2) The Matrix Misquote
Next is a misquote from yet another incredibly famous film franchise: The Matrix. It’s hard to forget about the choice Neo was given early in the series, or how Morpheus laid out the truth for him. This led to a memorable quote, “What if I told you?” that eventually became a massive meme online.
There’s just one problem: the quote didn’t happen. Instead of this meme-worthy line, Morpheus simply asks Neo if he wants to know the truth about the Matrix. Pretty straightforward, right? Is this a real-life glitch in the Matrix? Or did the wires get crossed somewhere else?
3) Shazaam Isn’t Real
People who grew up in the ’90s may be flabbergasted by this fact, but there never was a movie called Shazaam. Yeah, you read that right. A lot of people from this generation sincerely believe that Sinbad starred as a genie in a film called Shazaam. This one is arguably one of the most fascinating film examples of a Mandela Effect, as people can describe the details of Shazaam down to the VHS box cover. It feels so real, and yet there’s no real physical evidence of it.
So, how did this misconception happen? Well, there are a few theories. Sinbad happened to host a Movie Marathon in 1994, called Sinbad the Sailor, during which he was notably dressed as a genie. This was only two years before the release of Kazaam, in which Shaquille O’Neal played a genie. Given their proximity in style and release years, it almost makes a semblance of sense. On the bright side, Sinbad has been a pretty good sport about the whole misconception, even making a few jokes about it.
4) Freddy Krueger’s Sweater
Horror fans have never forgotten how A Nightmare on Elm Street helped change cinema as we know it. Interestingly, there is a visual example of a Mandela Effect happening in this film, and it revolves around Freddy Krueger’s look.
Think back to what Freddy Krueger is famously wearing in the film. His outfit includes that famous striped sweater, yes? What are the colors? Many people are quick to answer red and black, but that’s not entirely correct. Freddy Krueger’s sweater is actually red and green, and this isn’t an old version of the dress debate. A line from the film can quickly shut any debate down: “I dreamed a bad guy in a dirty red and green sweater.” Admittedly, there are several black and red sweaters in pop culture, so it could be a bit of basic confusion. However, you’ve got to give the writers credit for trying to directly import the colors into our brains.
5) Snow White’s Non-Existent Line
Snow White and the Seven Dwarfs is a Disney animated film that was released in 1937. That’s enough time to leave a mark on several generations, yet we still misremember how one of the most iconic scenes in the movie goes. Think back to the Queen’s words during her mirror scene. What do you hear in your head? For most people, it’s something along the lines of “Mirror, Mirror on the wall.” Right?
Well, that’s not how the Disney film has it. Her line is, “Magic Mirror on the wall.” This doesn’t sound quite as good, which may explain how people misremember it. Additionally, the Brothers Grimm version never called it a magical mirror, so it may have been society’s way of resisting that change.
6) C-3PO’s Legs in the Original Trilogy
Many fans were surprised by the drastic change to C-3PO’s looks in the latest Star Wars films, but this is actually not the first time the droid has been mismatched. Don’t believe us? Go back and rewatch the original Star Wars trilogy, but this time pay close attention to C-3PO’s legs. (Alternatively, you can just look at the image we’ve included.) He clearly has one gold and one silver leg.
To be fair, the color difference doesn’t stand out all that much, particularly on older quality film. Had this leg been in our faces with 4K quality, it’s far more likely that Star Wars fans would have picked up on this detail a lot faster.
7) The Silence of the Lambs‘ Famous Line Didn’t Happen
For years after The Silence of the Lambs dropped, people had so much fun spooking one another with that classic “Hello, Clarice” line. It still hits pretty hard today, even though the film has been out for decades. There’s just one problem: that line didn’t happen. We know that most fans can practically hear Anthony Hopkins’s voice in their heads, but we promise we’re not making this one up.
In the film, Hannibal Lecter does greet Clarice with a chillingly calm statement, but it’s “Good morning.” Really, that’s it. Notably, Jim Carrey played a role in The Cable Guy that poked fun at Hannibal Lecter, and he does drop the infamous line. Given that the parody happened a mere five years later, this may explain how it became so widespread. Or it may be a symptom of the phenomenon if the parody thought they were simply quoting the line.
8) Gremlins Name Shenanigans
Fans immediately fell in love with the magic of Gremlin, and to be fair, Gizmo’s face is pretty endearing. Naturally, a sequel was made, and that’s where our next Mandela Effect takes place. The film introduces a bunch of Gremlins as antagonists, including one primary green monster whose name people can not agree on.
Fans of the film will happily declare that he is named Spike. However, dolls and products from the film clearly label this Gremlin as Stripe. That may not sound like the biggest difference, but it was enough to confuse franchise fans and collectors.
9) “E.T. Home Phone”
E.T. the Extra-Terrestrial became famous for a lot of things, from the memorable bike scene to many remarkable lines dropped throughout the film. However, one quote has been misremembered to the point that it falls into Mandela Effect territory. Most people have certainly heard the phrase “E.T. phone home,” right?
Here’s the thing: that line got a little messed up in translation. The real line in the film is actually “E.T. home phone.” Remember, this is an alien doing its best to communicate to humans through their language, so a perfect translation wasn’t likely.
10) Casablanca’s Misquote
Casablanca is quoted so often that even those who have never seen the film can recognize its impact. That said, there’s one iconic line that never quite happened, despite public conception. Most fans will recall Humphry Bogart saying, “Play it again, Sam.” But that never happened.
If that line never occurred, then what happened? Truthfully, there is a different line in the film that has either been warped or misremembered. The line, spoken by Humphry Bogart, goes, “Play it once, Sam. For old times’ sake…Play it, Sam.” Is it pedantic to point this misquote out? Normally, the answer would be yes. However, this film is so iconic that it is shocking that anyone, especially film buffs, would allow it to pass by without commentary or complaint.
What pieces of movie trivia do you think are often misremembered? Let us know in the comments below!
Most Viewed
-
Image Courtesy of DC Comics -
Image Courtesy of DC Comics
